In an era where automobile prices are soaring and interest rates remain elevated, the decision to purchase a vehicle—whether new or used—has become a critical financial commitment. To assist consumers in making informed choices, Consumer Reports has developed comprehensive evaluation reports for all vehicles it tests. Through rigorous testing and analysis, CR aims to help buyers select cars that will serve them well for years to come.

Comprehensive Testing Reveals Top Performers

In the heart of this competitive automotive landscape, Consumer Reports' engineers and specialists conduct over 50 meticulous evaluations on each car they acquire. These assessments cover a wide range of criteria including road performance, comfort, reliability, owner satisfaction, and safety features. The organization compares more than 250 different models to provide detailed insights into each brand's strengths and weaknesses.

The results of CR’s 2025 report card reveal little change among the top five brands compared to the previous year. However, there is one notable shift: Subaru has emerged as the leading brand, edging out its competitors. Joining Subaru at the pinnacle are BMW, Lexus, Porsche, and Honda. Conversely, brands like Dodge, GMC, Land Rover, Rivian, and Jeep have been placed at the bottom of the rankings.

Despite the overall high ratings of top-performing brands, Consumer Reports cautions that individual models within these brands may not consistently meet the same standards. Therefore, it is crucial for potential buyers to conduct thorough research and review specific vehicle ratings before making a purchase. Additionally, CR provides guidance on pre-owned vehicles, highlighting Lexus, Toyota, and Mazda as standout used car brands.

From a consumer perspective, this report underscores the importance of due diligence when selecting a vehicle. Even the most reputable brands can have models that fall short in certain areas. By leveraging the extensive data provided by Consumer Reports, buyers can make more confident and informed decisions, ensuring their investment aligns with their needs and expectations.